CriticalDance Forum

It is currently Wed Sep 19, 2018 1:03 pm

All times are UTC - 7 hours [ DST ]

Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 22 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2
Author Message
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Fri Jun 30, 2006 10:01 am 

Joined: Wed Apr 12, 2000 11:01 pm
Posts: 688
Location: Seattle, WA. USA
Cygnet to Swan
Oregon Ballet Theatre’s “Swan Lake”
Saturday, June 10, 2006, 2:00 p.m. matinée
Keller Auditorium, Portland, Oregon

by Dean Speer

Well, good news! It’s a fine and opulent full-length “Swan Lake” and one that OBT and Portland ballet fans will be proud of for many years to come. This year’s reprise of Act III included a much improved ‘Russian’ dance, and removal of a misguided attempt to insert a mini back-story (thank you, Mr. Stowell!).

My only real “fuss” is the deletion of the music – and dance – for the “big” swans in Act II. It’s a glorious waltz and music that was missed.

Okay, another big fuss is how the conductor and the dancers missed each other. I’m not making this up. During the two pas de deux, there are many poses and movements that should be hitting the music just so, and it was a bit like watching an out-of-sync film. Roper and Sultanov were fine and even though it was clear that Neil DePonte was intently watching with baton in hand, there was too much of a delay between what we saw and what we heard. It got better, but for a while it was disconcerting. It may also be that this was the first time that this pair got an orchestra outing, since it was their first performance – their second being the following matinée on Sunday.

Alison Roper was fabulous in the dual role of Odette/Odile. Her strong technique was imbued with a sense of the fatalistic and tragic as the tender and love-needy Odette. Her Odile was layered with snarls and hidden fangs as she and père Rothbart (Paul De Strooper) worked on foiling Siegfried’s love for Odette.

[I have to keep asking myself: “And just who was Odile’s mother?” I had this strange notion come to mind while observing the Queen Mother and Rothbart chatting away on the thrones during Act III, that they seemed to get along just a little too well...hmmm. Could it be that our hapless prince and Odile are step-brother and sister? Egads! The tragic outcome of this ballet does keep the power structure right where it is.]

Roper’s Prince Siegfried, Artur Sultanov, is long of line and of Hollywood star visage and fundamentally he has good, underlying technique, but he seemed to run out of juice as the swans carried on. My initial reaction was that perhaps he’d become dehydrated during the show, but in pondering further have come to the conclusion that it’s an increase in stamina that he needs to work on. His Act III solo needed more oomph; however, the sense of flagging energy works fine in the concluding Act IV, where all is lost due to his zealous and mistaken pledge to Odile and how Odette and flock are doomed to eternal flapping.

Act I’s divertissements were handled nicely by both the choreographer and the groups that dance them. Particularly memorable and charming was the Pas de Trois with Daniela Deloe, Anne Mueller, and Jon Drake.

Act II’s ‘Four Little Swans’ received a well deserved ovation: Ansa Deguchi, Emily Tedesco, Natalie Wilson, and Holly Zimmerman. They were appropriately tight and swift of foot and head. It’s one of those numbers that audiences always look forward to and it does show off the dancers and the overall level of the company.

The corps was exquisite in this ballet blanc act. No surprise here given the coaching by Francia Russell and OBT’s ballet mistress, Lisa Kipp. I really like and appreciate how they had the swans keep their entrance motif à terre (step, hop in arabesque élongé and emboîtés devant, repeated) and how they gradually increased this same pattern to more of a springy sauté and vigor, perhaps suggesting the change of the characters from swans to maidens, per the legend.

Roper’s and Sultanov’s duet was limpid and spoke well of the two finding each other and of Odette placing her – and that of her cygnets – in this prince’s vow of eternal love, and hence their freedom from Rothbart’s spell. Roper’s supported pirouettes and stretch into arabesque were sustained just right.

Act III’s “Betrothal Ball” has built into the right amount of spirited character dances and classical pas. Among the latter were the Pas de Trois with Daniela Deloe, Anne Mueller, and Brennan Boyer and the pas for the six princesses at the ball – each vying for the hand of the prince: Candice Bouchard, Olivia Lavery, Amanda Simnitt, Rachel Simons, Emily Tedesco, and Natalie Wilson.

Of the former, the ‘Neapolitan’ dance was particularly sunny and was brightly danced by the fresh Ansa Deguichi and Steven Houser.

I was happy to see both the ‘Spanish’ and ‘Czardas’ in actual character shoes and boots. Too often, groups give in to the temptation to transfer the choreography to pointe for the women, and while it can be fun, it’s just not as effective or, for that matter, authentic. It was great seeing both done straight-forward with no muss nor fuss. They just gave us the dancing.

And since the ‘Russian’ dance was vastly improved, nay I’d have to say that it is as near to perfection as I’ve seen, I can now say what I thought last year and was sorely tempted to write, which was, “Poor dancer bouréeing around the stage looking for an exit!” This year’s – and hopefully final edition – has all the right stuff: soulful and slow beginning, quickly building to zesty passion with the right balance between classical pointe work and character port de bras (hand behind the head, or arms crossed and leaning into the hip to the side, etc.). This dance truly went somewhere and was satisfying to see. As all dances should, it had a clear beginning, middle, and end.

The Black Swan Pas de Deux was effective and is always one of those 12 or minutes of a ballet that we all wait for – and it’s worth it. Adagio was good. Roper nailed all the technical requirements of her solo – double pirouette, double attitude turns from fourth, nice long line on the attitude reversés, and a nice attack to show Odile’s aggressive nature on the rélevé arabesques. She didn’t quite power up to all 32 fouettés during the coda but that’s okay. I’ve seen all the way from 16 and then “other” to those who could do singles and doubles from beginning to end. The point is that she finished strongly and under control, and more importantly conveyed the idea behind this series of whipping turns – of hypnotizing the prince so he doesn’t notice poor Odette flapping outside the palace gates (in the rain?) who is trying to get the prince’s attention to make him realize he’s about to be duped and Odette to lose her turn at freedom and have to start over on the board game of love. Never mind that Siegfried is very handsome, very brave, very strong, and very stupid...

In Act IV, the prince begs for lakeside forgiveness, still hoping for love, redemption, and to be home in time to watch the 11 o’clock news, but while Odette does forgive him by a gesture – brushing his head, pushing it down so he won’t look at her, it’s really too late, and Odette is pulled back into her swan shape and is sent off at the dawn, presumably by Rothbart, perhaps to meet her own doom at the hand of another, unknowing hunter.

Great stuff, huh!

Hurray for OBT for mounting a standard version of this timeless classic and one that Northwest audiences will enjoy for a long time to come. Indeed, given only the first four, initial performances and the clamor for tickets, they could probably already offer more and reap the artistic and financial benefits such a “Swan Lake” can bring. Thanks also for providing live music and an able orchestra and conductor. It’s the magic of the music and the dance coming together that make for a memorable afternoon in the Rose City and one that illustrates how the cynet OBT is becoming an elegant, long-necked Swan.

Next year’s season promises more to look forward to:

Dean Speer

Reply with quote  
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Mon Jul 03, 2006 12:15 pm 

Joined: Tue Jan 04, 2000 12:01 am
Posts: 14250
Location: Seattle, WA, USA
Tim Duroche reviews "Swan Lake" for Willamette Week:

Willamette Week

Reply with quote  
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 22 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2

All times are UTC - 7 hours [ DST ]

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 9 guests

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group